Creativity through high-order source analysis

Martyn Bajkowski

Having graduated from Durham in 2007 Martyn started teaching in Cumbria, where he became head of department after his second year in a small 11-18 school. Having returned to his homeland, Wigan, Martyn is currently head of History at a large 11-16 school in Blackburn.

Follow @BajkowskiMr

Email This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Image credit: Flickr // thelowry. Image credit: Flickr // thelowry.

Despite all the educational changes that have happened since I started teaching History just under a decade ago, one thing has remained a constant. Source analysis is the hardest component for students to understand. This is part of my ‘why’ in that I do not remember any lesson in Secondary, A-level or degree that asked me to develop my ability to use sources. This may be me being incredibly disingenuous, and I am sure that any ability I have is not divined or been bestowed by anything other than practice. It may just have not been made as obvious to me it is now. Nevertheless I have constantly looked for ways to make source analysis more engaging, purposeful and develop the skills for students to engage in a real critique of sources.

Too often source analysis has been placed into easy-to-define statements. “It is a cartoon therefore it is mocking…”; “It is a drawing therefore we can’t be sure it actually happened…”; “It is from a historian therefore it is well researched and balanced…” Or perhaps worst of all, “the source is biased”. Instead of pulling my hair out at these statements which, apart from the word bias, all could be vaguely applicable to the source in question, I wanted to understand why students fell back on these phrases and why teachers taught them.

In part this is because true source analysis comes from being able to place yourself in the shoes of the person writing the source. That ability is problematic for students - particularly if Piaget is to be believed, when he said that students do not develop conceptual understanding until they are fourteen. Therefore they cannot imagine they are someone else.

This is then compounded by the fact that a lot of sources tend to come in a written form. Now, whether that is archaic language (simplified or not) or a more modern interpretation on an event, the problem for students is in the nature of the source. It’s just like emails and texts from being people that you do not know, meaning can be misconstrued easily. Implicit messages are not picked up on because - firstly - this is not the main type of communication nowadays and - secondly - students cannot place themselves into the mind of the author whether they know of them or not.

Strategy 1

If studying whether or not Edward II was murdered or escaped to Italy, I needed my students to understand the people both behind the investigation and indeed behind the source. Now, I am unfortunately not one of“I wanted to understand why students fell back on worn-out phrases.” these amazing teachers that comes into lesson and can embody a character, treating students to a real insight into that person. Nor do I have the curriculum time to do this over a series of eight characters (four weeks). However, I can embody them in front of a camera with no one watching.

To do this you need to have a quiet space, allow for lots of retakes and, most importantly, prepare your script beforehand. The real gift is to try and drop the implicit inferences through visual cues such as tone, intonation, eye contact (or lack thereof) that students will pick up on which allows them to look for meaning behind the dialogue.

YouTube link

YouTube link

Result 1

Once they know that something is afoot, students can start probing the material deeper, asking the key questions like:

  • “What has gone on beforehand?”
  • “When did he say it?”
  • “How does it fit in the chronology of events?”
  • “Who is he affiliated to?”
  • “What is the purpose of the source?”

By providing accessible interpretations of past characters you not only make the story come to life, but you also create a vehicle for students to want to delve deeper into the past through their questioning of the material.

This allows them to start developing a web of links between characters, producing work that reaches substantive judgements based on high level source analysis that is well-developed.

Strategy 2

Clearly this cannot be done for every lesson, but I would advocate that rather than adapting sources based purely on language that you adapt it so that it is more conversational English. In a lesson to introduce public health in Roman times, I created an investigation into the murder of a fictional character called ‘Stickilus’ who stuck Mosaics to a wall. In these sources below, I added text so that pupils could see literary plot breaks in answers and start to question why that was.

Result 2

This allows them to study 11 sources and reach a conclusion that it was the Gladiator (Maximuscules) in conjunction with the Senator and Merchant (Dodgydealirous) who had a secret cartel that Stickilus had uncovered. This ability to cross reference source material and come to a substantial judgment and the answers they produce are of the highest order.

Above all, I believe in this approach in Key Stage 3 because I have seen the results of this immersion in their ability to analysis sources that are more complex as they develop. They start asking the right questions of source material, and start making good judgments as a result.

However the overriding reason I believe in this is because it allows them to encounter so many of the great mysteries of the past and have their say on them. It builds a thirst for knowledge and empirical enquiry that goes beyond the classroom. By selecting a form of sources that is accessible to them, they can see the best stories in history and we can see their best analysis.

Resource: Romans Who Killed Stickilus cards

Want to receive cutting-edge insights from leading educators each week? Sign up to our Community Update and be part of the action!

Register for free to continue reading
Registration is a free and easy way to support us.
When you register, you'll join a grassroots community where you can:
• Enjoy unlimited access to articles
• Get recommendations tailored to your interests
• Attend virtual events with our leading contributors
Register Now

Latest stories

  • How to handle stress while teaching in a foreign country
    How to handle stress while teaching in a foreign country

    Teaching English in a foreign country is likely to be one of the most demanding experiences you'll ever have. It entails relocating to a new country, relocating to a new home, and beginning a new career, all of which are stressful in and of themselves, but now you're doing it all at once. And you'll have to converse in a strange language you may not understand.

  • Is Learning Fun for You, Teacher?
    Is Learning Fun for You, Teacher?

    Over the weekend, my family of five went to an Orlando theme park, and I decided we should really enjoy ourselves by purchasing an Unlimited Quick Queue pass. It was so worth the money! We rode every ride in the park at least twice, but one ride required us to ride down a rapidly flowing river, which quenched us with water. It was incredible that my two-year-old was laughing as well. We rode the Infinity Falls ride four times in one day—BEST DAY EVER for FAMILY FUN in the Sun! The entire experience was epic, full of energizing emotions and, most importantly, lots of smiles. What made this ride so cool was that the whole family could experience it together, the motions were on point, and the water was the icing on the cake. It had been a while since I had that type of fun, and I will never forget it.

  • Free recycling-themed resources for KS1 and KS2
    Free recycling-themed resources for KS1 and KS2

    The Action Pack is back for the start of the brand new school year, just in time for Recycle Week 2021 on 20 - 26 September, to empower pupils to make the world a better and more sustainable place. The free recycling-themed resources are designed for KS1 and KS2 and cover the topics of Art, English, PSHE, Science and Maths and have been created to easily fit into day-to-day lesson planning.

  • Inspire your pupils with Emma Raducanu
    Inspire your pupils with Emma Raducanu

    Following the exceptional performance from British breakthrough star Emma Raducanu, who captured her first Grand Slam at the US Open recently, Emmamania is already inspiring pupils aged 4 - 11 to get more involved in tennis - and LTA Youth, the flagship
    programme from The LTA, the governing body of tennis in Britain, has teachers across the country covered.

  • 5 ways to boost your school's eSafety
    5 ways to boost your school's eSafety

    eSafety is a term that constantly comes up in school communities, and with good reason. Students across the world are engaging with technology in ways that have never been seen before. This article addresses 5 beginning tips to help you boost your school’s eSafety. 

  • Tackling inequality in EdTech
    Tackling inequality in EdTech

    We have all been devastated by this pandemic that has swept the world in a matter of weeks. Schools have rapidly had to change the way they operate and be available for key workers' children. The inequalities that have long existed in communities and schools are now being amplified by the virus.

  • EdTech review & The Curriculum Lab
    EdTech review & The Curriculum Lab

    The world is catching up with a truth that we’ve championed at Learning Ladders for the last 5 years - that children’s learning outcomes are greatly improved by teachers, parents and learners working in partnership. 

  • Reducing primary to secondary transition stress
    Reducing primary to secondary transition stress

    As school leaders grapple with the near impossible mission to start bringing more students into schools from 1st June, there are hundreds of thousands of Year 6 pupils thinking anxiously about their move to secondary school.

  • Generation Z and online tutoring: natural bedfellows?
    Generation Z and online tutoring: natural bedfellows?

    The K-12 online tutoring market is booming around the world, with recent research estimating it to grow by 12% per year over the next five years, a USD $60bn increase. By breaking down geographic barriers and moving beyond the limits of local teaching expertise, online tutoring platforms are an especially valuable tool for those looking to supplement their studies in the developing world, and students globally are increasingly signing up to online tuition early on in their secondary education schooling. 

  • Employable young people or human robots?
    Employable young people or human robots?

    STEM skills have been a major focus in education for over a decade and more young people are taking science, technology, engineering, and maths subjects at university than ever before, according to statistics published by UCAS. The downside of this is that the UK is now facing a soft skills crisis and the modern world will also require children to develop strong social skills as the workplaces are transformed by technology. 

In order to make our website better for you, we use cookies!

Some firefox users may experience missing content, to fix this, click the shield in the top left and "disable tracking protection"